This is a bit of a shock....'Bestlife' talked to food and travel experts to get their take on the top pizza spots in the US! You may be thinking Chicago? New York? Well, hold onto your pizza slice because the BIG winner was Providence, Rhode Island! Providence was chosen for its top-rated Sicilian pies. That meant New York City was pushed to second place for US pizza cities. The big shocker is that instead of Chicago...Detroit is actually the third best city for pizza lovers; known for its chewy, deep dish curst and as the home of Domino's and Little Caesar's. San Francisco came in fourth for any of the 20 pizzarias along the city's North Beach. New Haven, Connecticut rounds out the top five US pizza cities.